Discussão:Victor de Aveyron

O texto seguinte foi movido de: Victor de Aveyron [1]

The english version of Wikipedia gaves the following major datas, that should be translated and added to this article :

In March 2008, following the disclosure that the best seller book and movie " Survivre avec les loups" (Survival with wolves) was a swindle, there has been an important debate in the French media (newspapers, radio and even on television) concerning the numerous false cases of feral children blindly accredited : though there are numerous books on this subject, almost none of them have been based on archives, the authors using rather dubious second or third-hand printed information. According to the French surgeon Serge Aroles, who has written a general study of feral children based on archives (L'Enigme des Enfants-loups or The Enigma of Wolf-children, 2007), almost all of these cases are scandalous swindles or totally fictitious stories.

According to Serge Aroles, who gives several clues in Chapter XXXI of his book, Victor of Aveyron is not a genuine feral child. "Don't forget that Truffaut's movie is ... a movie !" And, something worse, for the surgeon Serge Aroles, the scars on the body of Victor were not the consequences of a wild life in the forests, but rather of physical abuse.

[edit] Bibliography • For the first opportune critical approach based on archives : Serge Aroles, L'Enigme des enfants-loups (The Enigma of wolf-children), 2007, ISBN-10: 2748339096.—o comentário precedente não foi assinado por 87.91.248.30 (discussão • contrib.) Gunnex ^{msg contrib} 10h36min de 16 de Maio de 2008 (UTC)