Discussão:Popeye Village

WP:VPV. O "R" Aliado ^✉ 23h41min de 14 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)

Hi @O revolucionário aliado: (sorry for speaking EN); yesterday's edits [1] [2] by Patvs and ActualMaltesePerson were legitimate. The Popeye Village and the Danish Village, both in Mellieha, are two different things. Only the latter was designed by Hans Munk Hansen, not the first. Two of the sources you added (ToM and MHC) are about the Danish village; the third source (lamattinadigital.com.br) is a low-quality news source, which probably took its info from this same page, hence a circular reference. I am an active editor on en.wiki, it.wiki and mt.wiki and I've raised the issue with the mt.wiki community, hopefully this can be fixed. There are already way too many articles out there confusing the two, which are probably sourced from this page. Many thanks for taking a look! --Dans (discussão) 08h20min de 15 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)

PS: [3] here you have a ToM article about Munk Hansen mentioning how he built the Danish Village in 1975-77. Nowhere in the article is it mentioned the Popeye Village, which was built as a film set of the 1980 Musical Production 'Popeye', and with which Munk Hansen had nothing to do. --Dans (discussão) 08h30min de 15 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)

Hi @Dans: Thank you for the explanation. With the explanatory source, it is now possible to have reasonable action, unlike accounts that only eliminate and do not justify or justify speculatively (this is not how you contribute to the WP-PT) .O "R" Aliado ^✉ 20h52min de 15 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)

Hey PT editors. Sorry for not knowing Wikipedia editing etiquette. I thought I was clear in my Edit Notes. But I'll try to explain it again. Danish architect Hans Munk Hansen recently died. To my surprise if you google him he is attributed to having designed Popeye Village. I understand the confusion as he designed the Danish Village. This Times of Malta article shows a picture of The Mellieħa Holiday Centre, also known as the Danish Village. Perhaps you will notice it's not the same as Popeye Village. Popeye Village and the Danish Village, both in Mellieha are two different things as a previous editor pointed out. This is why the Popeye Village wiki pages in 12 other languages, and the page on the architect don't mention it. Only the PT page (and Armenian) does. Your current source (Referência: Preservation of modernist architecture Times Malta doesn't mention Popeye Village for good reason. Because Popeye Village has nothing to do with the architect. Conclusion: you must first come to the understanding Popeye Village is not the same as the Danish Village. Therefore Hans Munk Hansen did not design Popeye Village (he did design the Danish Village). And please be more careful of a circular/self reference, listing a reference based on your own article as the PT Popeye Village page has been the main source of this misinformation for years now. --Patvs (discussão) 19h34min de 16 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)

@Patvs: não necessitamos de suas preocupações. Sua ação aqui é considerada WP:PATO sem WP:V. O "R" Aliado ^✉ 22h22min de 16 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)

Hi @O revolucionário aliado:, I've replaced the two wrong sources with appropriate ones about the Popeye Village, and removed the reference to Munk Hansen, who is not linked to this place as explained above. Obrigado! --Dans (discussão) 09h34min de 28 de agosto de 2021 (UTC)