Wikipédia:Esplanada/geral/Condados / Condes (11out2023)
 |
Condes (11out2023)
Hello, I do not understand Portuguese, but I found some issue: My bot is connecting on Wikidata categories with articles using artigo principal da categoria (P301) and categoria principal do tópico (P910). Both category and article should have same name, bot can also merge unconnected categories with other languages when there is same P301. When working on administrative divisions, i found here some categories named Category:Condado de XXX containing Category:Condes de XXX. But article Condado de XXX' is on Wikidata connected with pt category Condes de XXX instead of Condado de XXX. There should be wrong connection of some category or wrong name of category - but only in few cases it is conflicted. See Categoria:Condado de Vienne which have no P301 and Category:Condes de Vienne connected with Condado de Vienne. another case is Categoria:Condado de Vermandois and there should be more similar without conflict. I stopped work on these for now. JAn Dudík (discussão) 07h12min de 11 de outubro de 2023 (UTC)
- @JAn Dudík, condados have condes, just like kingdoms have kings; yet, not every king has a kingdom, just like a conde may have that title but not a condado to rule.
- About those categories, Categoria:Condado_Portucalense in pt.wiki is connected to Q8424462 (Categoria:Condado Portucalense) on Wikidata. And the article Condado_Portucalense is connected to Condado Portucalense (Q1139807)... Condados should be linked to Condados, and Condes should be linked to Condes. But here, on pt.wiki, you will find many times that we link, for example, Condes de Portucale to the main article Condado Portucalense.
- If this answer didn't help you, just tell us. Cheers, Luís Almeida "Tuga1143 10h02min de 11 de outubro de 2023 (UTC)
- OK, So there are deliberatery(?) inaccurate connections. In few cases it causes some type of conflict on Wikidata. It is up to you, pt.wiki community, if you want to repair it or not, these categories are on few wikis only. JAn Dudík (discussão) 06h16min de 12 de outubro de 2023 (UTC)
- @JAn Dudík, I am not sure I understood the problem correctly. Your first examples does not use our {{lp|Cat principal}} template to specify the main article for the category. This seems to be something you have to clarify with d:User:Ghuron at Wikidata and whoever else is adding those properties at Wikidata. GoEThe (discussão) 11h12min de 12 de outubro de 2023 (UTC)
- OK, So there are deliberatery(?) inaccurate connections. In few cases it causes some type of conflict on Wikidata. It is up to you, pt.wiki community, if you want to repair it or not, these categories are on few wikis only. JAn Dudík (discussão) 06h16min de 12 de outubro de 2023 (UTC)