Wikipédia:Esplanada/geral/Japanese footballers (29jun2016)
 |
Japanese footballers (29jun2016)
Hello. Excuse me. In 2013, I created Japanese footballers articles. For example, Jiro Miyake. But, these articles has been removed because I did not add reliable source. (see also Wikipédia:Páginas para eliminar/Jiro Miyake).
Recently, I created these articles again. But these article was requested for deletion [1]. So, I added a reliable source (e.g. Predefinição:NFT player) [2]. But, the source was removed and these article was requested for deletion again [3]. Why is the source removed? Why are these article requested deletion? --Japan Football (discussão) 13h20min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- Japan Football None of these articles, and their respective sources reach our notability policies. Also, in 2014, the community of pt wiki decided to eliminate these articles of 1920 japan footballers, once that the sources doesn't show any relevance of this players. Mjuniifale comigo 13h25min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- Predefinição:NFT player is used many articles as source. Is this not reliable source? Which is 2014s discussion? I want to see that discussion. --Japan Football (discussão) 13h43min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- See the discussion here. Mjuniifale comigo 13h47min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- Wikipédia:Páginas para eliminar/Yoshikazu Nonomura are not Japanese national football team players, so Predefinição:NFT player does not exist. So, I did not add reliable source. According to the discussion, because I did not add reliable source and those player are notability player, those articles have been removed. But this time, I created Japanese national football team players and I added the source. --Japan Football (discussão) 14h07min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- Dear @Japan Football: According to our current polices and guidelines, "having a source" is not enough to assert notability. An article about a soccer player must satisfy WP:DESPORTISTAS and/or WP:CDN. Kind regards --Usien6 D C E F 15h05min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- Wikipédia:Páginas para eliminar/Yoshikazu Nonomura are not Japanese national football team players, so Predefinição:NFT player does not exist. So, I did not add reliable source. According to the discussion, because I did not add reliable source and those player are notability player, those articles have been removed. But this time, I created Japanese national football team players and I added the source. --Japan Football (discussão) 14h07min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- See the discussion here. Mjuniifale comigo 13h47min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
- Predefinição:NFT player is used many articles as source. Is this not reliable source? Which is 2014s discussion? I want to see that discussion. --Japan Football (discussão) 13h43min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
What is the relevance of "articles" that say no more than "Someone was a football player of the team X and played in one or two games of a regional competition 90 years ago"? The question would be hard to answer even if football was a relevante sport in Japan in that time or now!!! --Stegop (discussão) 14h17min de 29 de junho de 2016 (UTC)
Japan Football, you should not create articles in Wikipédias of languages you don't understand. If you can't speak portuguese, you can't read the rules about creation of articles, so you will be unable to follow them.--Mister Sanderson (discussão) 02h53min de 6 de agosto de 2016 (UTC)